Books/Movies

Naked Among Wolves

颐光 2017. 5. 15. 17:00


Taking place at the Concentration camp Buchenwald at the end of March 1945, prisoner Hans Pippig discovers in a carrying case of an incoming prisoner a Jewish child. If reported the ... See full summary »

Director:

Writers:

(novel), (screenplay)

Stars:

, ,

User Reviews

 
Not quite a true story
17 January 2016 | by See all my reviews

The film is based on a novelization of the true story of a boy who was brought to Buchenwald with his father (not a stranger as depicted in the film) near the end of the war, while the mother and sister were killed in Auschwitz. The novel was written by a man who himself was a prisoner at Buchenwald for eight years, which lends credibility to the scene he paints. Nevertheless, some aspects of the situation in the camp and some dramatic events in the story were implausible. For me this undercut the grim realism and emotional impact of the film. It turns out that the actual story is both more tragic and morally ambiguous (search "buchenwald boy guardian" to learn more), whereas the film rather simplistically aims to depict "the best and worst of humanity."


'Books > Movies' 카테고리의 다른 글

In Darkness  (0) 2017.05.15
The English Patient  (0) 2017.05.15
the devil’s arithmetic  (0) 2017.05.15
FUGITIVE PIECES  (0) 2017.05.15
The Pawnbroker  (0) 2017.05.15